Batman Television Series Cast: A Look at the Actors Who Could Have Been Batman

The 1960s Batman television series starring Adam West remains a pop culture icon. West’s portrayal of the Caped Crusader, along with Burt Ward as Robin, defined the dynamic duo for a generation. But what if other actors had landed the role? Several names were considered, and some even screen-tested for the part. Let’s delve into the “what ifs” of the Batman Television Series Cast.

James Garner, known for his roles in Maverick and other popular series, was a talented actor, but his laid-back demeanor might not have suited the role of the brooding Batman. While some might argue he possessed the physicality reminiscent of comic book characters, his acting style leaned more towards charming rogue than dark knight.

Even Jack Kelly, Garner’s Maverick co-star, might have been a more suitable choice for Batman than Garner himself. Although Kelly’s performance in a Catwoman two-part episode wasn’t particularly memorable, he arguably possessed a more serious acting style that could have potentially translated to the role of Batman.

Another potential Batman was Mike Henry, known for portraying Tarzan. While he had the physique for the role, his acting skills might not have been sufficient to carry a series like Batman. The demands of the character require not just physical presence but also a certain charisma and dramatic range.

Lyle Waggoner, who later starred in Wonder Woman, actually screen-tested for Batman. Contrary to popular belief, he wasn’t rejected for being too serious. His interpretation was actually considered too campy, and his high-pitched voice didn’t quite fit the character. Adam West, a more seasoned actor, delivered a more nuanced and compelling performance.

Dick Gautier, primarily known for his comedic roles, also comes up in discussions about the Batman casting. He even appeared in a Batgirl public service announcement. While he did a decent Adam West impression, it’s unclear how he would have portrayed Batman without West’s performance to emulate.

Finally, there’s Jack Lord, famous for Hawaii Five-O. Although he might seem like an unconventional choice, Lord was a serious contender for Captain Kirk in Star Trek around the same time as the Batman series. While his age might have been a concern, even in 1966, he possessed the commanding presence and serious demeanor that could have made for a very different Batman.