Reaper Television Series: A Casting Controversy
The CW’s “Reaper” television series faced early controversy surrounding a significant casting change. Nikki Reed, initially cast as the female lead and love interest for Bret Harrison’s character, was replaced by Missy Peregrym, known for her role as the illusionist Candice on “Heroes.” This decision sparked debate and concern among fans and critics alike.
Reed, having garnered acclaim for her work in independent films and popular television series like “The O.C.,” was seen as a promising addition to the “Reaper” cast. Her performance on “The O.C.” showcased her maturity, charm, and acting capabilities, leaving many to believe she would bring depth and intrigue to the role in “Reaper.”
Alt: Nikki Reed, originally cast in the Reaper television series.
Conversely, Peregrym’s previous roles on “Life as We Know It” and “Heroes” had not generated the same level of enthusiasm. While her performance in certain scenes of “Heroes” displayed potential, her character, Candice, was often perceived as lacking dynamism and engaging qualities necessary for a compelling love interest. This led to questions about her suitability for the role in “Reaper,” a series that aimed for a quirky and engaging tone.
The age difference between the actresses also fueled the discussion. Reed, closer in age to the character’s purported age of 21, was considered a more authentic fit. Peregrym, being 25 at the time, sparked debate about whether the age gap would impact the character’s portrayal and overall chemistry with Harrison’s character. Ultimately, the concern was whether Peregrym could capture the nuanced performance required for the role, potentially hindering the show’s overall quality and appeal. Fans worried that her casting might lead to a less captivating and potentially stereotypical female character, detracting from the series’ unique premise and potential. Whether Peregrym could defy expectations and deliver a compelling performance remained to be seen, but the casting change undoubtedly left a mark on the early perception of the “Reaper” television series.
