Reaper Casting Controversy: Nikki Reed Replaced by Missy Peregrym

The CW’s “Reaper” faced early controversy when Nikki Reed, initially cast as the female lead, was replaced by Missy Peregrym (“Heroes”). This decision sparked debate among fans and critics.

Reed, known for her work in independent films and “The O.C.,” was considered a promising addition to the cast. Her performance on “The O.C.” showcased her talent and potential, leading many to believe she would excel in “Reaper.”

Nikki Reed, originally cast as the female lead in the CW's Reaper.

Conversely, Peregrym’s roles in “Life as We Know It” and “Heroes” hadn’t generated the same level of excitement. While she showed potential in “Heroes,” her character, Candice, was often seen as lacking the dynamism needed for a compelling love interest. This raised questions about her suitability for “Reaper.”

The age difference also fueled discussion. Reed, closer to the character’s purported age of 21, was considered a more authentic fit. Peregrym, being 25, sparked debate about the age gap’s impact on the character’s portrayal and chemistry with Bret Harrison. Concerns arose about Peregrym capturing the role’s nuances, potentially hindering the show’s quality. Fans worried her casting might lead to a less captivating female character, detracting from the series’ unique premise. Whether Peregrym could defy expectations remained to be seen, but the casting change impacted the early perception of “Reaper.”