Aussie Cop Shows: Reality vs. Representation
Summer TV in Australia often sees a surge in local police reality shows. These documentaries follow a formula, stretching incidents into hour-long episodes, offering viewers a glimpse into the daily routines of law enforcement. But the popularity of these “television cops” raises questions about their appeal and impact.
Why are these shows so popular? For many from working-class backgrounds, the relationship with law enforcement is complex. Working-class families often have members in the police force, yet also experience disproportionate harassment. This creates a conflicting perspective, where respect for authority clashes with lived experiences.
Political discourse further complicates this. Some activists condemn the police as oppressive, while others recognize individual officers, often from working-class backgrounds, who share similar concerns as the communities they police. The reality is nuanced, with police misconduct existing alongside dedicated service.
Police reality TV offers a unique window into working-class labor. Unlike crime dramas, these shows depict mundane policing: paperwork, waiting, and the occasional pursuit. This representation of everyday work resonates with viewers, demystifying a profession often shrouded in secrecy.
The shows also educate. Viewers learn police jargon, procedures, and consequences for offenses. Observing breathalyzer tests or the reading of rights highlights procedural aspects of law enforcement. Furthermore, the shows often touch upon social issues like alcohol abuse, domestic violence, and mental health.
Entertainment comes from the thrill of “riding along” with officers, experiencing the tension of arrests and chases. There’s a voyeuristic element to observing both police and the public, offering a glimpse into human behavior under pressure.
However, these shows also function as PR for law enforcement. By cooperating with filmmakers, police departments present a carefully curated image. While minor imperfections may be shown, serious issues like brutality or corruption are absent. This sanitized portrayal contrasts with news reports of misconduct.
While entertaining and informative, these shows present a limited perspective. The absence of critical issues creates a sanitized image of policing, neglecting the complex relationship between law enforcement and the community. Enjoying the depiction of working-class jobs shouldn’t preclude critical examination of the gaps in representation and the often fraught relationship between the working class and the police.
