A Deep Dive into the Supergirl Television Show and its Comic Book Tie-in
The Supergirl Television Show, a live-action adaptation of the DC Comics character, has captivated audiences with its compelling storyline and strong female lead. This success, however, highlighted a curious gap in DC’s comic book lineup: a Supergirl comic that resonated with the show’s tone and audience. This article explores the history of this disconnect and delves into the creation of a comic book series specifically designed to complement the Supergirl television show.
DC’s Supergirl Conundrum: A Comic Book Void
Despite the positive reception of the Supergirl television show, DC Comics faced a challenge. The publisher had canceled its ongoing Supergirl comic series due to low sales prior to the show’s premiere. This left a void in the market for fans eager to explore Supergirl’s adventures in comic book form. The problem was compounded by the fact that previous Supergirl comic iterations, often entangled in complex continuity reboots and featuring vastly different characterizations, didn’t align with the TV show’s modern, empowering portrayal. The show presented a simplified, relatable Supergirl, a stark contrast to some of the more convoluted or hyper-sexualized versions in previous comics.
ADVOSG_01_D_Cover
Bridging the Gap: The Adventures of Supergirl Comic Series
To address this issue, DC launched The Adventures of Supergirl, a digital-first comic series intended to bridge the gap between the television show and the comic book world. Written by Sterling Gates, who had previously penned a successful run on the Supergirl comic from 2005-2011, and featuring art by Bengal, known for his work on Batgirl comics, the series aimed to capture the essence of the TV show. Notably, this new series was set within the continuity of the television show, mirroring the approach taken with comics based on other DC TV shows like Arrow and The Flash. This decision, while potentially limiting the comic’s reach to solely TV show fans, offered a direct connection to the beloved on-screen portrayal of Supergirl.
Capturing the Spirit of the Show: Challenges and Successes
The Adventures of Supergirl embraced the core elements of the show, focusing on Supergirl’s work with the Department of Extranormal Operations (DEO) to combat alien threats. The first chapter even reintroduced a classic Superman villain, Rampage, showcasing Supergirl’s powers and incorporating flashbacks to her origin story, directly mirroring the TV show’s opening sequence. While the comic successfully replicated the action and adventure of the show, it faced the inherent challenge of translating the unique qualities of the television medium into a static visual format. The charisma of Melissa Benoist’s performance, the sharp wit of Calista Flockhart’s character, and other nuanced elements of the show were difficult to fully capture on the comic book page.
A Unique Approach: Catering to a Specific Audience
By setting the comic within the TV show’s continuity, DC adopted a strategy that prioritized appealing to existing fans of the Supergirl television show. This approach, while potentially excluding a broader comic book audience, provided a tailored experience for those seeking a direct extension of the on-screen narrative. The comic, while competent in its storytelling and artwork, ultimately served as a companion piece to the show rather than a standalone Supergirl comic with wider appeal.
Conclusion: A Step in the Right Direction
The Adventures of Supergirl, while perhaps not the definitive Supergirl comic book experience, offered a valuable addition for fans of the television show. It provided a way to engage with the character and world in a new format, expanding upon the stories told on screen. While a comic set within the main DC Universe might have had broader appeal, this series successfully filled a specific niche, demonstrating DC’s responsiveness to the demands of its audience and showcasing the enduring popularity of the Supergirl character across different media. The series provided a crucial link between the screen and the page, ultimately enhancing the overall Supergirl experience for dedicated fans.
