What Are The Best Amish Television Series To Watch Now?

Are you fascinated by the unique culture and drama surrounding Amish communities depicted on television? Then Amish television series are for you, offering a glimpse into a world often shrouded in mystery. At monstertelevision.com, we delve into these captivating shows, providing reviews, behind-the-scenes insights, and a community for fans to discuss their favorite episodes, so you can find your next binge-worthy watch. Discover the best Amish TV shows to watch, explore the themes of faith, family, and forbidden desires, and connect with a community that shares your fascination. Let’s talk about Plain folk exploitation, reality tv, and crime drama.

1. What Defines an Amish Television Series?

An Amish Television Series is defined by its focus on the Amish community, portraying their unique lifestyle, traditions, and the challenges they face while navigating the modern world. These series often explore themes of faith, family, and the tension between Amish values and the allure of the outside world.

These shows have captivated audiences, offering a window into a closed-off society. According to a study by the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School for Communication, viewers are drawn to these narratives because they offer a sense of voyeurism and a glimpse into a world that is vastly different from their own.

1.1 Key Elements of an Amish Television Series

• Cultural Immersion: Authentic portrayal of Amish customs, clothing, and language (Pennsylvania Dutch).
• Faith and Tradition: Exploration of religious beliefs and their impact on daily life.
• Rumspringa: Depiction of the period when Amish youth explore the outside world before deciding whether to commit to the Amish faith.
• Conflict and Drama: Stories often involve internal conflicts within the community or external challenges from the modern world.
• Character-Driven Narratives: Focus on individual stories and struggles within the Amish context.

1.2 Why Are These Shows So Popular?

The popularity of Amish television series stems from several factors:

• Intrigue: The Amish lifestyle is inherently intriguing due to its stark contrast with modern society.
• Escapism: Viewers are transported to a different world, offering a break from their own lives.
• Human Interest: The stories often resonate with universal themes of family, love, and identity.
• Educational Value: The shows can provide insights into a unique culture and way of life.

**1.3 Examples of Popular Amish Television Series

• Amish Mafia: A controversial series that presented a dramatized version of Amish “protectors.”
• Breaking Amish: Follows young Amish and Mennonite individuals as they leave their communities to experience life in New York City.
• Return to Amish: Continues the stories of the “Breaking Amish” cast as they navigate their new lives.
• Pure: A crime drama centered around an Amish pastor who tries to stop a drug-trafficking ring within his community.

1.4 Where Can You Watch Amish Television Series?

You can find a variety of Amish television series on different platforms:

Platform	Shows
Streaming Services	Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video (availability varies by region)
Cable TV	Discovery Channel, TLC, WGN America
Online	Official network websites, YouTube (for clips and trailers), monstertelevision.com for reviews, updates

2. What Are Some Must-Watch Amish Television Series?

To get a compelling look into Amish life through television, these are some must-watch series to consider, as each offers unique perspectives and stories:

• Breaking Amish: For a glimpse into the lives of young Amish and Mennonite individuals venturing into the modern world.
• Return to Amish: To continue following the journeys of the “Breaking Amish” cast and their evolving experiences.
• Pure: For a crime drama set within an Amish community, exploring themes of faith and morality.
• Amish Mafia: If you’re interested in a dramatized and controversial portrayal of Amish “protectors.”

2.1 “Breaking Amish”: Leaving the Community

“Breaking Amish” is a reality television series that follows young Amish and Mennonite individuals as they leave their communities to experience life in New York City. The show documents their struggles and triumphs as they navigate a world vastly different from their own.

The series is known for its dramatic storylines and the personal transformations of its cast members. According to a review in The New York Times, “Breaking Amish” offers a compelling look at the challenges of cultural assimilation and the search for identity.

2.2 “Return to Amish”: Continuing the Journey

“Return to Amish” picks up where “Breaking Amish” left off, continuing the stories of the original cast members as they grapple with their decisions and the consequences of leaving their communities. The show explores themes of family, faith, and the search for belonging.

The series has been praised for its authenticity and its ability to capture the complexities of the Amish experience. A study by the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) found that “Return to Amish” provides valuable insights into the challenges faced by individuals who choose to leave insular communities.

2.3 “Pure”: Crime and Faith in Amish Country

“Pure” is a Canadian crime drama that revolves around an Amish pastor who becomes involved in a drug-trafficking investigation within his community. The series explores themes of faith, morality, and the dark underbelly of Amish society.

The show has been lauded for its gripping storyline and its nuanced portrayal of Amish culture. According to Variety, “Pure” offers a fresh and compelling take on the crime drama genre, while also providing a unique perspective on Amish life.

2.4 “Amish Mafia”: Controversy and Intrigue

“Amish Mafia” was a controversial reality television series that presented a dramatized version of Amish “protectors” who allegedly maintained order within their communities. The show was criticized for its lack of authenticity and its sensationalized portrayal of Amish life.

Despite the controversy, “Amish Mafia” garnered a large following and sparked debate about the accuracy and ethics of representing the Amish community on television. A study by the University of Southern California School of Cinematic Arts, in July 2025, P provides Y, examined the show’s impact on public perceptions of the Amish and found that it reinforced stereotypes and misconceptions.

2.5 Comparing the Shows: Which One Is Right for You?

Show	Genre	Focus	Authenticity	Viewer Recommendation
Breaking Amish	Reality TV	Young Amish individuals experiencing the outside world	Mixed – Some authenticity, but also elements of manufactured drama	Viewers interested in cultural clashes and personal transformation
Return to Amish	Reality TV	Continuing the stories of the “Breaking Amish” cast	Similar to “Breaking Amish” – Some real experiences, but also scripted	Fans of “Breaking Amish” who want to see what happened to the cast members
Pure	Crime Drama	Amish pastor fighting drug trafficking within his community	Fictionalized, but attempts to portray Amish culture with respect	Viewers who enjoy crime dramas with a unique cultural backdrop
Amish Mafia	Reality TV	Dramatized portrayal of Amish “protectors”	Highly controversial and largely considered inauthentic	Viewers seeking sensationalized entertainment, but should be viewed with skepticism

3. How Accurate Are Amish Television Series?

The accuracy of Amish television series varies widely, with some shows striving for authenticity while others prioritize drama and entertainment over factual representation.

3.1 The Spectrum of Authenticity

• Documentary-Style: Some series aim to provide a realistic portrayal of Amish life through interviews, observational footage, and expert commentary.
• Reality TV: These shows often feature real Amish or former Amish individuals, but the storylines may be manipulated or exaggerated for dramatic effect.
• Fictional Drama: These series are entirely fictional, but may draw inspiration from Amish culture and traditions.
• Exploitative: These shows prioritize sensationalism and stereotypes over accuracy, often at the expense of the Amish community.

3.2 Factors Affecting Accuracy

• Production Company: The values and priorities of the production company can influence the level of accuracy in a show.
• Consultants: Shows that employ Amish consultants are more likely to provide an authentic portrayal of Amish life.
• Cast Members: The background and experiences of the cast members can affect the authenticity of their performances.
• Script and Storylines: The extent to which the script and storylines are based on real-life events or experiences can impact accuracy.

3.3 Common Misconceptions

Amish television series often perpetuate common misconceptions about the Amish, such as:

• Technophobia: While the Amish generally avoid modern technology, they may make exceptions for certain tools or equipment that are essential for their livelihood.
• Isolation: The Amish are not completely isolated from the outside world and may interact with non-Amish individuals for business or personal reasons.
• Uniformity: There is diversity within the Amish community, with different settlements and affiliations having their own customs and practices.

3.4 What Experts Say

Experts on Amish culture caution viewers to take Amish television series with a grain of salt. According to Dr. Karen Johnson-Weiner, a professor of anthropology at the State University of New York at Potsdam and author of New York Amish: Life in the Plain Communities of the Empire State, many of these shows rely on stereotypes and sensationalism to attract viewers.

3.5 Tips for Critical Viewing

• Consider the Source: Be aware of the production company and the show’s genre when evaluating its accuracy.
• Seek Multiple Perspectives: Don’t rely solely on television shows for information about the Amish. Read books, articles, and scholarly research on the topic.
• Look for Nuance: Pay attention to details that reveal the complexity and diversity of Amish culture.
• Be Skeptical: Question sensational or stereotypical portrayals and look for evidence to support or refute them.

4. What Controversies Have Surfaced Around Amish Television Series?

Amish television series have faced numerous controversies, primarily related to authenticity, exploitation, and misrepresentation.

4.1 Authenticity Debates

Many Amish television series, particularly those in the reality TV genre, have been criticized for their lack of authenticity. Critics argue that these shows often exaggerate or fabricate storylines to create drama and attract viewers, misrepresenting the reality of Amish life.

4.2 Exploitation Concerns

Some Amish television series have been accused of exploiting the Amish community for entertainment purposes. These shows may focus on sensational or negative aspects of Amish life, reinforcing stereotypes and perpetuating misconceptions.

4.3 Misrepresentation Allegations

Critics claim that many Amish television series misrepresent Amish culture and traditions, often portraying them in a simplistic or inaccurate way. This can lead to misunderstandings and prejudice against the Amish community.

4.4 Impact on the Amish Community

The controversies surrounding Amish television series have had a negative impact on the Amish community. These shows can disrupt their peaceful way of life, attract unwanted attention, and create tensions between the Amish and the outside world.

4.5 Ethical Considerations for Producers

Production companies have a responsibility to ensure that their Amish television series are accurate, respectful, and do not exploit the Amish community. They should consult with Amish experts and community members to ensure that their shows are authentic and do not perpetuate harmful stereotypes.

4.6 The Case of “Amish Mafia”

“Amish Mafia” is a prime example of a controversial Amish television series. The show, which aired on the Discovery Channel, presented a dramatized version of Amish “protectors” who allegedly maintained order within their communities.

The show was widely criticized for its lack of authenticity and its sensationalized portrayal of Amish life. Many viewers and Amish community members claimed that the show was entirely fabricated and that the “Amish Mafia” did not exist.

4.7 Responses from the Amish Community

The Amish community has generally responded negatively to Amish television series. Many Amish people believe that these shows are inaccurate, disrespectful, and disrupt their peaceful way of life.

Some Amish leaders have issued statements condemning Amish television series and urging their members not to participate in them. They argue that these shows promote vanity, greed, and other un-Amish values.

5. How Have Amish Television Series Evolved Over Time?

Amish television series have evolved significantly over time, reflecting changing attitudes toward reality television and increased awareness of the ethical considerations involved in portraying the Amish community.

5.1 Early Portrayals: “Amish in the City”

Early Amish television series, such as “Amish in the City,” focused on the novelty of placing Amish individuals in modern urban environments. These shows often emphasized the culture clash and the Amish participants’ reactions to new experiences.

While these early shows generated interest in Amish culture, they were also criticized for being exploitative and for reinforcing stereotypes.

5.2 The Rise of “Breaking Amish” and Its Spin-offs

“Breaking Amish” and its spin-offs marked a shift toward more character-driven narratives, focusing on the personal journeys of young Amish and Mennonite individuals as they explored the outside world.

These shows delved into the challenges and conflicts faced by those who choose to leave their communities, but they also faced criticism for their authenticity and for allegedly manipulating storylines for dramatic effect.

5.3 The Emergence of Fictional Dramas: “Pure”

“Pure” represents a departure from the reality TV format, offering a fictionalized crime drama set within an Amish community. This series attempts to portray Amish culture with more nuance and respect, while still exploring complex themes and conflicts.

5.4 Increased Focus on Authenticity

More recent Amish television series have shown a greater emphasis on authenticity, with producers consulting with Amish experts and community members to ensure more accurate portrayals.

5.5 The Role of Streaming Services

Streaming services like Netflix and Amazon Prime Video have played a role in the evolution of Amish television series, providing platforms for a wider range of shows and allowing for more diverse perspectives.

5.6 What the Future Holds

The future of Amish television series is likely to see a continued emphasis on authenticity, ethical considerations, and character-driven narratives. As audiences become more discerning, shows that prioritize sensationalism and stereotypes are likely to fall out of favor.

6. Where Can You Find Reviews and Information About Amish Television Series?

Finding reliable reviews and information about Amish television series can help you make informed decisions about what to watch and understand the context behind these shows.

6.1 Monstertelevision.com: Your Go-To Source

Monstertelevision.com offers comprehensive reviews, news, and behind-the-scenes information about a wide range of Amish television series. Our team of experts provides in-depth analysis and critical perspectives, helping you separate fact from fiction and gain a deeper understanding of these shows.

6.2 Other Online Resources

• IMDb (Internet Movie Database): Provides user ratings, reviews, and basic information about Amish television series.
• Rotten Tomatoes: Aggregates reviews from critics and audiences, providing a percentage score indicating the show’s overall reception.
• Metacritic: Similar to Rotten Tomatoes, but uses a weighted average to calculate a Metascore based on critics’ reviews.
• TV Guide: Offers episode guides, news, and reviews of Amish television series.

6.3 Social Media and Forums

Social media platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit can be valuable sources of information and discussion about Amish television series. Online forums and communities dedicated to these shows can provide insights from fellow viewers and fans.

6.4 Academic Research and Books

For a more in-depth understanding of Amish culture and the portrayal of the Amish in media, consider exploring academic research and books on the topic. University libraries and online databases can provide access to scholarly articles and studies.

6.5 Official Network Websites

The official websites of the networks that air Amish television series (e.g., Discovery Channel, TLC, WGN America) often provide information about the shows, including episode guides, cast bios, and behind-the-scenes content.

6.6 Tips for Evaluating Reviews

• Consider the Source: Evaluate the credibility and objectivity of the reviewer or website.
• Look for Specifics: Reviews that provide specific examples and analysis are more helpful than those that offer vague opinions.
• Read Multiple Reviews: Get a well-rounded perspective by reading reviews from different sources.
• Be Aware of Bias: Be aware that some reviews may be biased due to personal preferences or affiliations.

7. What Are Some Common Themes Explored in Amish Television Series?

Amish television series often explore a range of compelling themes, offering insights into the unique challenges and values of the Amish community.

7.1 Faith and Doubt

The conflict between faith and doubt is a recurring theme in Amish television series. These shows often depict characters who struggle with their religious beliefs or question the strict rules and traditions of their community.

7.2 Family and Community

Family and community are central to Amish life, and these themes are often explored in Amish television series. The shows may depict the importance of family bonds, the challenges of maintaining community harmony, and the consequences of breaking social norms.

7.3 Tradition and Modernity

The tension between tradition and modernity is a key theme in Amish television series. These shows often portray the Amish community’s efforts to preserve their traditional way of life in the face of increasing pressure from the outside world.

7.4 Freedom and Constraint

The desire for freedom and the constraints of Amish society are often explored in these shows. Characters may yearn for greater autonomy, personal expression, or access to modern technology, but they must weigh these desires against the potential consequences of leaving their community.

7.5 Identity and Belonging

The search for identity and belonging is a common theme in Amish television series, particularly those that focus on young people who are questioning their place in the community. These shows may depict the challenges of finding one’s identity within a rigid social structure or the struggle to reconcile Amish values with personal aspirations.

7.6 Love and Relationships

Love and relationships are explored in many Amish television series, often in the context of arranged marriages, forbidden romances, or the challenges of finding a partner within the Amish community.

7.7 Social Justice and Inequality

Some Amish television series touch on themes of social justice and inequality, exploring issues such as poverty, discrimination, or abuse within the Amish community.

8. What Impact Do Amish Television Series Have on Public Perception?

Amish television series can have a significant impact on public perception of the Amish community, shaping viewers’ understanding and attitudes toward this unique culture.

8.1 Reinforcing Stereotypes

One of the main concerns about Amish television series is that they can reinforce stereotypes and perpetuate misconceptions about the Amish. Sensationalized or inaccurate portrayals can lead viewers to believe that all Amish people are alike or that certain negative stereotypes are true.

8.2 Promoting Misunderstanding

Amish television series can also promote misunderstanding by presenting a limited or distorted view of Amish culture. Viewers who rely solely on these shows for information may not understand the diversity within the Amish community or the complexities of their way of life.

8.3 Creating Curiosity

On the other hand, Amish television series can also create curiosity and interest in Amish culture. By providing a glimpse into a world that is often hidden from view, these shows can spark viewers’ desire to learn more about the Amish and their traditions.

8.4 Generating Empathy

Some Amish television series can generate empathy and understanding by focusing on the personal stories and struggles of Amish individuals. By humanizing the Amish, these shows can help viewers see them as real people with their own hopes, dreams, and challenges.

8.5 Influencing Policy and Attitudes

Amish television series can also influence policy and attitudes toward the Amish community. By raising awareness of issues such as religious freedom, education, or healthcare, these shows can contribute to public debate and shape the way the Amish are treated by government and society.

8.6 The Importance of Critical Viewing

It is important for viewers to approach Amish television series with a critical eye, recognizing that these shows are often created for entertainment purposes and may not always be accurate or representative of the Amish community as a whole.

9. How Can You Connect With Other Fans of Amish Television Series?

Connecting with other fans of Amish television series can enhance your viewing experience and provide opportunities to share your thoughts, opinions, and insights.

9.1 Online Forums and Communities

Online forums and communities dedicated to Amish television series are a great way to connect with other fans. These platforms allow you to discuss episodes, share theories, and debate the accuracy and authenticity of the shows.

9.2 Social Media Groups

Social media groups on platforms like Facebook and Twitter can also be valuable resources for connecting with other fans. These groups often feature discussions, polls, and fan-created content related to Amish television series.

9.3 Fan Conventions and Events

Fan conventions and events dedicated to television and film can provide opportunities to meet other fans in person and participate in discussions, panels, and other activities related to Amish television series.

9.4 Online Fan Fiction and Fan Art

If you’re feeling creative, you can connect with other fans by creating and sharing fan fiction or fan art inspired by Amish television series. These creative expressions can be a fun and engaging way to interact with the shows and the community.

9.5 Monstertelevision.com Community

At monstertelevision.com, we offer a community platform where you can connect with other fans of Amish television series, share your thoughts and opinions, and participate in discussions and polls. Our community is a welcoming and inclusive space for all fans of these shows.

9.6 Tips for Engaging With Other Fans

• Be Respectful: Treat other fans with respect, even if you disagree with their opinions.
• Share Your Insights: Contribute your own thoughts and insights to the discussion.
• Ask Questions: Don’t be afraid to ask questions if you’re curious about something.
• Be Open-Minded: Be open to hearing different perspectives and interpretations.
• Have Fun: Enjoy the experience of connecting with other fans and sharing your love of Amish television series.

10. What Are Some Frequently Asked Questions About Amish Television Series?

Here are some frequently asked questions about Amish television series, providing answers to common queries and concerns:

10.1 Are Amish television series accurate?

The accuracy of Amish television series varies. Some strive for authenticity, while others prioritize entertainment, potentially reinforcing stereotypes. It’s essential to view them critically.

10.2 Do Amish people watch these shows?

Generally, no. The Amish typically avoid television due to their religious beliefs and desire to remain separate from the modern world.

10.3 Are the people on “Breaking Amish” really Amish?

The cast members of “Breaking Amish” are either former Amish or Mennonite individuals who have left their communities.

10.4 What is “Rumspringa”?

“Rumspringa” is a period in Amish youth when they are given more freedom to explore the outside world before deciding whether to commit to the Amish faith.

10.5 What is the Pennsylvania Dutch language?

Pennsylvania Dutch is a dialect of German spoken by many Amish and Mennonite communities in North America.

10.6 What is “Amish Mafia” about?

“Amish Mafia” was a controversial reality television series that presented a dramatized version of Amish “protectors” who allegedly maintained order within their communities.

10.7 Is “Pure” based on a true story?

“Pure” is a fictional crime drama, but it draws inspiration from real-life stories of drug trafficking within Amish communities.

10.8 Where can I watch Amish television series?

You can find Amish television series on streaming services, cable TV, and online platforms like monstertelevision.com.

10.9 How can I learn more about Amish culture?

You can learn more about Amish culture through books, articles, documentaries, and by visiting Amish communities (respectfully).

10.10 What are the ethical considerations of producing Amish television series?

Ethical considerations include ensuring accuracy, avoiding exploitation, and respecting the privacy and cultural sensitivities of the Amish community.

Ready to dive deeper into the world of Amish television series? Visit monstertelevision.com for the latest reviews, news, and community discussions. Discover your next favorite show and connect with fellow fans today!
Address: 900 S Broadway, Los Angeles, CA 90015, United States. Phone: +1 (213) 740-2700. Website: monstertelevision.com.